A while ago, I was doing some research on A.R.T. in Boston, and I saw they were putting on a musical called Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York).
"Why on Earth," I wondered, "would a theatre in Boston be producing a new musical about New York City?" The answer, of course, was it was in development for Broadway, having already played London's West End.
The piece was written by Jim Barne and Kit Buchan, two Brits who channeled their enthusiasm for far-off, exotic New York into the character of Dougal, a young man from the United Kingdom visiting the U.S. for the first time. Dougal is a bit... much.
Fortunately, his naive enthusiasm is balanced by Robin, a New Yorker who grew up in Flatbush and currently works at a coffee shop in Manhattan, waiting not for her big break, but to figure out what it is she wants to do with her life. Right at the top of the show, we get a musical contrast in their attitudes as he sings the soaring anthem "New York" and she has a quiet but beautiful number called "What'll It Be" as she begins her day in the coffee shop.
The show promises the plot in its title, but for greater context, the cake in question is a wedding cake, and the reason the two people are strangers is that they are related to the couple getting married in different ways. (He's the groom's estranged son, while she's the bride's younger sister.) Things get complicated when a layer of the cake gets dropped, but rather than going in the expected direction of the two protagonists trying frantically to fix their mistake, the play makes a curious turn in the Act One closer "American Express" as they decide to go all out with a borrowed credit card.
While the bride and groom never appear in this two-character play, we do get a sense of them, and the more the play goes on, the more we feel their pending matrimony will be a disaster, and a dropped cake is the least of their worries.
I finally caught up with the play this past weekend, and I have to say it is delightful. If you have a chance to see it, go.






